Hit "Enter" to search or "Esc" to close.

Your privacy is important to us.

This website uses cookies to help deliver its services. By using this website, you agree to the use of cookies as outlined in our Cookie Policy.

  • Home
  • Sectors & Solutions
    • Brexit Legal Support
    • Charities & Social Enterprises
    • COVID-19 Solutions
    • Energy & Renewables
    • InterTradeIreland Emergency Business Solutions
    • Manufacturing Law
    • Property Developers & Construction
    • Technology Law
  • Expertise
    • Banking & Finance
    • Commercial
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Construction
    • Corporate & M&A
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment
    • Planning & Environment
    • Foreign Direct Investment
    • Insolvency & Business Restructuring
    • Intellectual Property & Technology
    • Personal Legal Matters
    • Private Equity & Venture Capital
    • Public Procurement
    • Public & Administrative
    • Tourism & Licensing
  • People
  • News & Insights
    • News
    • Legal Insights
    • Social
  • About
    • About Us
    • Clients
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Join Our Team
    • Join Our Team
    • Trainee Programme
    • Why Choose Cleaver Fulton Rankin?
  • CFR HR
  • Get In Touch
Cleaver Fulton Rankin Solicitors, Belfast Logo
Contact
  • Sectors & Solutions
    • Brexit Legal Support
    • Charities & Social Enterprises
    • COVID-19 Solutions
    • eLearning
    • Energy & Renewables
    • InterTradeIreland Emergency Business Solutions
    • Manufacturing Law
    • Property Developers & Construction
    • Technology Law
  • Expertise
    • Banking & Finance
    • Business & Private Immigration Law
    • Commercial
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Construction
    • Corporate & M&A
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment
    • Planning & Environment
    • Foreign Direct Investment
    • Insolvency & Business Restructuring
    • Intellectual Property & Technology
    • Personal Legal Matters
    • Private Equity & Venture Capital
    • Public Procurement
    • Public & Administrative
    • Tourism & Licensing
  • People
  • News & Insights
    • News
    • Legal Insights
    • Social
  • About
    • About Us
    • Clients
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Join Our Team
    • Join Our Team
    • Trainee Programme
    • Why Choose Cleaver Fulton Rankin?
  • CFR HR
  • Get In Touch
Get In Touch

Future obligations under Income Payments Order discharged by second Bankruptcy

< Back to Legal Insights

A recent Court of Appeal case in England considered the question of whether future payments due by a discharged bankrupt under an Income Payments Order (IPO) were provable debts in his second bankruptcy.

Facts

Mr A (a bankrupt) argued that an IPO that remained extant after his discharge from his first bankruptcy was automatically discharged upon his second bankruptcy. His Trustee in Bankruptcy argued that the future payments were not provable as they were uncertain due to the Courts ability to vary them and should remain enforceable for the benefit of the first bankruptcy estate. The Trustee did however accept that arrears under the IPO were provable debts in the second bankruptcy.

The legislation is clear that if a second bankruptcy order is made before the debtor is discharged from the first bankruptcy then the IPO becomes an asset of the second bankruptcy and the second trustee can collect the payments for his estate. However, there is no provision for what is to happen to an IPO if the second bankruptcy order is made after the debtor receives their discharge from the first bankruptcy order.

Decision

At first instance, the District Judge held that the future payments under the IPO were enforceable as they were not provable in the second bankruptcy. This decision was upheld by the High Court. Mr A appealed to the Court of Appeal.

In a leading Judgment, Richards LJ found that arrears due under an IPO and Future IPO payments were provable debts in the second bankruptcy under the Insolvency Act 1986 (the “Act”). The judgment considered the wording of section 335 of the Act. The equivalent article of the Insolvency (Northern Ireland) Order 1989 is article 308.

He also noted that the Act did not expressly except future payments under an IPO or dictate their survival following a bankrupt’s discharge from bankruptcy. Therefore, there were important policy reasons to apply the Supreme Court decision in Re Nortel GmbH (In Administration) [2013] UKSC for consistency.

Comment

This decision fills a gap in the Income Payment Order provisions of the Act and would be persuasive in Northern Ireland in respect of the equivalent provisions of the Order. A Trustee of a first bankruptcy must now prove in a second bankruptcy for arrears and future payments under an IPO and the second Trustee can apply for a new IPO.

Azuonye v Kent [2019] EWCA Civ 1289

This article has been produced for general information purposes and further advice should be sought from a professional advisor. Please contact our Insolvency & Business Restructuring team at Cleaver Fulton Rankin for further advice or information.

Rachel Kelly, Associate , Insolvency & Business Restructuring team, Cleaver Fulton Rankin, Solicitors.


« Previous Article
Next Article »

Author(s)


Person Thumbnail

Rachel Kelly

Associate

Email Icon    |    view profile

How can we help you?


Call us on the Belfast number below or send us a message and one of our team will be in touch.

028 9024 3141
Send us a Message

How can we help you?


Contact
GDPR Compliance *

Related Areas


  • Banking & Finance
  • Dispute Resolution
  • Banking Disputes & Recoveries
Cleaver Fulton Rankin Logo

Belfast Commercial Law Firm:

Cleaver Fulton Rankin,
50 Bedford Street,
Belfast, BT2 7FW

Tel: 028 9024 3141
E: info@cfrlaw.co.uk

Social Media Icon Social Media Icon Social Media Icon

Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy
Disclaimer

© 2021 Cleaver Fulton Rankin - Solicitors, Belfast
Created by WebsiteNI

Current Awards

Award
Award
Award

Social Media Icon Social Media Icon Social Media Icon

Privacy Policy    |    Cookie Policy    |    Disclaimer

© 2021 Cleaver Fulton Rankin - Solicitors, Belfast    |    Created by WebsiteNI

© 2021 Cleaver Fulton Rankin - Solicitors, Belfast    |    Responsible Business    |    Privacy Policy    |    Cookie Policy    |    Disclaimer    |    Created by WebsiteNI

Social Media Icon Social Media Icon Social Media Icon